The Temptation of “Cute Venues”

At first glance, the idea of hosting a murder mystery in a library or cafe feels perfect. A library has that hushed, scholarly vibe. A cafe smells like coffee and baked goods. Both settings sound like a dream… until you actually start picturing twenty of your friends arguing at full volume about who poisoned the heiress. Suddenly the “dream” setting turns into a logistical nightmare.

The Reality Check

Libraries don’t usually want groups shouting accusations in their reading rooms. Cafes have background noise, strangers staring, and staff wondering why your friend is fake-dying near the pastry case. Unless you manage to snag a private library room, neither of these venues really works the way you imagine.

Better to Test It Small First

Here’s a smarter approach: try a tiny mystery with your group at home before renting a venue. That way you can see how everyone reacts to roleplay, laughter, and accusations without committing to a big setup. We’ve made this easy for you with a quick, lighthearted mini game that doesn’t require a full guest list.

It only takes about 15 minutes, works with 3–5 players, and swaps the murder for laughs. Think of it as a practice round that shows you how fun (and chaotic) a mystery can be.

Click Here

Where Hosting Actually Works Best

Most of our customers run their mysteries at home, and honestly, it’s the simplest option. Your living room or dining room can transform into a train car, a Hollywood set, or even a jungle base camp if you’ve got the right script. That’s the magic of using polished kits like The Emerald Expedition or The Grand Gilded Express—the pacing, character roles, and evidence keep people engaged no matter where you play.

What If Home Isn’t Ideal?

Not everyone has space for a dozen players. If your home doesn’t work, here are solid alternatives:

• Private library room: Some libraries let you reserve community rooms, which gives you the ambiance without the shushing.
• Church classrooms: Many churches with daycares have classrooms they rent out cheaply. Tables, chairs, and restrooms are already in place.
• Community centers: These often have flexible meeting spaces with easy parking.

All of these give you privacy, space, and the freedom to laugh without glaring strangers wondering what’s going on.

Why Script Quality Beats Venue Choice

Here’s the real truth: your venue matters less than the game itself. A well-paced murder mystery doesn’t leave downtime for guests to get bored. For example, Murder at Copper Gulch is built to keep the action rolling. Every round has objectives, secrets, and evidence that keep players busy. Nobody is staring at their phone because they’re too busy suspecting their friends.

What Goes Wrong at Cafes

Hosting in a public cafe usually means:

• Competing with blenders, music, and general chatter.
• No real privacy for in-character scheming.
• Guests feeling awkward about “performing” in front of strangers.

You want your players comfortable and focused on the mystery—not on the guy at the next table trying to eavesdrop on their fake alibi.

What Goes Wrong at Libraries

Without a private room, libraries have similar pitfalls:

• Volume restrictions make it hard to build drama.
• Food and drink rules limit snacks and drinks, which are half the fun.
• Other patrons won’t appreciate a staged “murder” happening by the biography section.

Again, if you can get a private room, great. Otherwise, the setting works against you instead of helping.

Simple Beats Complicated

The easiest way to guarantee success? Keep it simple. Host at home, decorate lightly, and rely on the story to carry the night. Our mysteries are designed so that once the introductions start, momentum builds naturally. From jungle legends to Old Hollywood scandals, your players won’t be thinking about the room—they’ll be too busy pointing fingers and defending themselves.

How to Pick Your Mystery

Your venue question should really follow your theme choice, not the other way around. Choose the kit that excites your group:

• The Emerald Expedition for adventure seekers who love Indiana Jones energy.
• The Grand Gilded Express for vintage glamour and train-bound tension.
• Murder at Copper Gulch (coming soon) for a Western showdown full of grit and charm.

Once you pick your story, any decent private space can transform into the perfect backdrop.

The Bottom Line

Should you host a murder mystery at a library or cafe? Not unless you’ve booked a private room. Both options sound romantic but usually end in frustration. If you’ve got the space, home hosting is your best bet. If not, community rooms and church classrooms beat “cute” public spots every time.

What matters most is the script you choose, not the walls around you. With polished pacing, strong characters, and built-in suspense, your guests won’t even notice where they are. They’ll be too busy solving the crime.

Make Your Choice Easy

The fastest way to build confidence is to try a short mystery first. Once you see how much fun your group has, you’ll know exactly where to host your full event. Grab our free mini game and test it out.

Click Here