Want to make your mystery night unforgettable?

Costumes and props are the secret sauce. You can have the best script in the world—like The Emerald Expedition or The Grand Gilded Express—but if everyone shows up in jeans and T-shirts, it’s just not the same. Once people slip into character with a trench coat, a cowboy hat, or a sparkly 1930s gown, the whole thing transforms. Suddenly, the “game” feels like a movie.

The best part? You don’t need to spend a fortune or rent out a theater costume closet. With a few creative shopping stops, you can turn your living room into Copper Gulch, a jungle expedition, or a luxury train car faster than you can say, “Who did it?”

1. Thrift Stores: The Goldmine of Props and Costumes

If you take only one thing from this post, let it be this: start at a thrift store.
Goodwill, Salvation Army, or any local secondhand boutique in a nice part of town—these places are treasure chests for mystery hosts.

You’ll find:

• Vintage hats, scarves, and costume jewelry.
• Old suitcases, maps, and binoculars for explorer themes.
• Formalwear straight out of the 1930s for your Grand Gilded Express evening.
• Vests, bandanas, and denim for Murder at Copper Gulch.

The trick? Visit thrift stores in wealthier neighborhoods. It’s not snobbery—it’s strategy. Those stores usually have higher-quality pieces that look like movie costumes instead of leftover Halloween rejects.

Pro tip: Bring your character list when you go. If you know someone’s playing “Dr. Felicia Fossil,” you can keep an eye out for a khaki jacket or leather satchel.

2. Amazon: The Ultimate Fast-Fix

If you’ve got two-day shipping and zero patience, Amazon is your best friend. It’s perfect for last-minute essentials—fake magnifying glasses, detective hats, feather boas, or prop pocket watches.

Type “1920s costume accessories” or “archaeologist explorer outfit” and you’ll find full sets for under $30. Not everything looks screen-accurate, but it’ll pass in dim lighting and a crowd full of laughter.

Use Amazon for:

• Prop weapons (foam, plastic, or vintage replicas).
• Accessories like monocles, gloves, and fake pearls.
• Bulk decorations—lanterns, vines, ropes, and wanted posters.

Still, don’t rely on it for everything. The algorithm can be… unpredictable. One minute you’re looking at a flapper dress, the next you’re knee-deep in inflatable dinosaur costumes. Browse carefully.

3. Temu: The Planner’s Paradise

Temu is for those who live dangerously—or at least plan dangerously far ahead. Shipping can take a couple of weeks (sometimes more), but the prices are shockingly low. You can grab props that look expensive for under $10.

It’s great for small accent pieces:

• Faux gold coins or “antique” jewelry for treasure themes.
• Fake mustaches, scarves, and hats for character flair.
• Vintage-style lanterns or compasses that look great in photos.

If your event is two months away, go wild. But if it’s next Friday? Don’t even try. You’ll end up explaining to guests why the detective’s hat is “still on a boat somewhere.”

Quick Break: Want to Test Your Group’s Acting Skills?

Before you commit to full costumes and props, give your group a practice run. We’ve got a free mini mystery that’s short, funny, and easy to set up. It’s perfect for testing how your 3-5 person crew handles character play without all the pressure—or the shipping delays.
Click Here

4. Facebook Marketplace: Hidden Gems (and Red Flags)

Marketplace can be a goldmine if you’re patient and picky. You’ll find everything from antique furniture to full vintage wardrobes—but also the occasional overpriced Halloween mask from 2007.

Search for:

• Old trunks, mirrors, or decorative items for scene setting.
• Formalwear or vintage coats sold by theater hobbyists.
• Bundles of costume jewelry or hats being sold after estate sales.

If you’re buying locally, always check items in person. Photos can lie—what looks like a “classic fedora” might be a crushed hat with glitter glue. And don’t pay full price for anything that smells like a haunted attic.

5. Dollar Stores & Party Supply Shops

Don’t underestimate the dollar store. You can stock up on candles, tablecloths, fake flowers, magnifying glasses, and old-fashioned notebooks for under $20 total.

Party supply stores also carry themed sections—like Western, 1920s, or Adventure Night—that can be perfect for quick props. It’s not high fashion, but it gets the job done when you’re hosting a 10-player mystery on a budget.

6. Your Own Closet (Seriously)

Before spending a dime, raid your own wardrobe. Half the time, you already have something that works.

A few ideas:

• A long trench coat instantly becomes detective gear.
• A sundress and pearls can turn anyone into a 1930s heiress.
• That old camping hat? Perfect for an explorer.
• Work boots, scarves, and cardigans—hello, frontier blacksmith.

Pair those with a little confidence and commitment, and your guests won’t care that the “antique magnifying glass” came from your kid’s science kit.

7. Prop Essentials You Should Always Have

You don’t need to fill your house with random stuff, but there are a few evergreen props that work across nearly every mystery:

• Clipboards or journals for note-taking detectives.
• Faux maps or scrolls (printable on regular paper).
• Lanterns, ropes, or candles for ambience.
• A fake microphone, envelope, or key for clue reveals.

These reusable pieces can live in a storage bin for future games. Because let’s be honest—you’ll want to host again.

8. Costume Tips for Big Groups

When you’re hosting a large group, not everyone will dress up. That’s okay. Keep a “prop basket” at the door filled with easy add-ons—badges, hats, scarves, fake glasses, and character name tags. It instantly helps people feel part of the story.

Offer small prizes for “Best Costume” or “Most Dramatic Performance.” The tiniest incentive turns even the shy guests into Oscar-level actors.

9. Keep It Safe and Simple

If you’re buying props, always stick to foam, rubber, or cardboard for anything that looks like a weapon. Nobody wants your mystery night to turn into an actual police call.

Also, avoid anything messy—like glitter bombs or fake blood—unless you love vacuuming until the end of time. Go for clean, creative, and reusable props.

10. The Best Combo: One Statement Piece per Guest

You don’t need a full costume to look the part. Just one item can transform someone instantly.

• A feathered headband for a flapper.
• A fake mustache for a cowboy.
• A notebook and spectacles for a professor.
• A silk scarf for a mysterious traveler.

Keep it simple, keep it fun. Mystery nights are about laughter, not wardrobe stress.

Ready to Play in Style?

Once your props are prepped and your guests are dressed, the magic happens. The story comes alive, the clues start to unfold, and you suddenly realize—this is better than any movie night.

Grab your costumes, print your character cards, and turn your evening into an unforgettable adventure. If you want to try a shorter game before going full-scale, grab the free mini mystery below and test your sleuthing chops first.
Click Here